27 Comments
User's avatar
Sofia Steinhagen's avatar

Congratulations to all who made this possible. Justice for Palestine

Alan, aka DudeInMinnetonka's avatar

Nils A. Haug (Gatestone Institute)

Israel is the rightful and eternal ancestral homeland of the Jewish people.

Much of the world nevertheless seems eager to believe lies about Israelis being colonialists - despite the inconvenient fact that the Jews fought colonialism, administered by the British.

Jews have been rooted to Israel (Zion) for nearly 4,000 years, backed by a promise in Genesis 15:18 that God made to the ancient father of all Jews: Abraham.

Muslims have been around only since the exploits of Mohammed - who died in 632 CE.

It would be considered laughable for the natives of any other country to be asked to defend their right to exist; why are Jews expected, after almost 4,000 years on the land, to explain their rights to Israel being their homeland?

Does anyone ask if Germany has a right to exist? Or Kazakhstan?

In today's uncomfortable reality, jihadists do not seem even slightly interested in giving up murdering Jews.

A strong and secure Israel will come only through a dynamic policy of self-defense that will be able to meet those striving for the country's elimination with determination.

The world is not just getting less safe for Jews. It is also rapidly becoming less safe for Christians, Hindus and Muslims deemed by other Muslims to be not Muslim enough.

No one seems to mind having eight officially Islamic states (Afghanistan, Brunei, Iran, Mauritania, Oman, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, and Yemen) and 18 states where Islam is the state religion, and one officially Anglican state, England, but they apparently cannot tolerate one small Jewish state.

As the leaders in the West increasingly lose their moral compass and kneel to appease the radical Jew-haters in their midst, the Jews hold the moral high ground; their critics and enemies do not.

Urvasi Devi Dasi's avatar

My grandfather served in the Signals Corps of the British Army. He arrived by ship to the port of Haifa in November 1937. Everything I know about his time there comes from a single photo album — a quiet archive of the images he captured: scenes of daily life in the markets, British and indigenous soldiers, ancient buildings, and Palestinians in traditional clothing.

Since recently learning about his posting ( after my father passed the album on to me ) I’ve been grappling with what this connection means in the context of what is happening there today. My grandfather was a kind, jovial man who married into a Maltese family. It’s difficult for me to imagine him as oppressive, and yet he would have been required to follow orders regardless of what he personally thought about the politics of the time.

That tension — that question of complicity across generations — sits heavily on my shoulders as I try to process it all.

I’m currently writing a longer piece that I’ll share here on Substack, including some of the photographs from his album, along with my thoughts and reflections on this complex inheritance.

Gothic Bluebird's avatar

It would be wonderful if the photos could be shared to an archive for all to learn from. Best wishes with your writing. 🕊️

Matthew Gumm's avatar

It is abundantly clear that you are treating this with the care and respect it deserves ❤️ Thank you for sharing. I wish you well on your journey.

Alan, aka DudeInMinnetonka's avatar

As you write be sure and include all of the documentation on top of the Bible where God gave Israel to the Jews and Jesus was crucified for being a Zionist on top of that the modern legitimization of Israel began with the anglo-american agreement, the San Remo treaty and the Balfour declaration which was abrogated by the British to supplicate the hashemites from Saudi Arabia and they gave away 78% of the land intended for the Jews.

The original peel agreement in 1936 which the British turned down was a postage stab size portion of land but every time the Jews agreed the Arabs disagreed

Nils A. Haug (Gatestone Institute)

Israel is the rightful and eternal ancestral homeland of the Jewish people.

Much of the world nevertheless seems eager to believe lies about Israelis being colonialists - despite the inconvenient fact that the Jews fought colonialism, administered by the British.

Jews have been rooted to Israel (Zion) for nearly 4,000 years, backed by a promise in Genesis 15:18 that God made to the ancient father of all Jews: Abraham.

Muslims have been around only since the exploits of Mohammed - who died in 632 CE.

It would be considered laughable for the natives of any other country to be asked to defend their right to exist; why are Jews expected, after almost 4,000 years on the land, to explain their rights to Israel being their homeland?

Does anyone ask if Germany has a right to exist? Or Kazakhstan?

In today's uncomfortable reality, jihadists do not seem even slightly interested in giving up murdering Jews.

A strong and secure Israel will come only through a dynamic policy of self-defense that will be able to meet those striving for the country's elimination with determination.

The world is not just getting less safe for Jews. It is also rapidly becoming less safe for Christians, Hindus and Muslims deemed by other Muslims to be not Muslim enough.

No one seems to mind having eight officially Islamic states (Afghanistan, Brunei, Iran, Mauritania, Oman, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, and Yemen) and 18 states where Islam is the state religion, and one officially Anglican state, England, but they apparently cannot tolerate one small Jewish state.

As the leaders in the West increasingly lose their moral compass and kneel to appease the radical Jew-haters in their midst, the Jews hold the moral high ground; their critics and enemies do not.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 29, 2025
Comment deleted
Urvasi Devi Dasi's avatar

No I'm not familiar, but thankyou for the link. They may be able to help with filling in some of the gaps.

Diane Engelhardt's avatar

It’s time for Palestinian film, Palestinian literature, Palestinian music, Palestinian art to take the world by storm!

goyo's avatar

So important and timely now that the UN Security Council voted again to keep occupying Palestine - without regard to Palestinian Freedom, sovereignty and involvement. Thank you to all involved

Michel Martinez's avatar

If things go as planned the UN will be replaced by a Sanhedrin. For those who do not know the UN was the 1st step towards building a One World Government another way of saying a Jewish World Order.

Matthew Gumm's avatar

I'm going to see it next weekend in a local independent studio, at a screening arranged by a local solidarity collective ❤️ I can't wait.

The mask has slipped and the world is waking up. Too slowly, but it is happening.

Diana van Eyk's avatar

This film sounds amazing, and you've captured its importance in your writing, Ahmed. Thank you. I hope to see it.

Alan, aka DudeInMinnetonka's avatar

Nils A. Haug (Gatestone Institute)

Israel is the rightful and eternal ancestral homeland of the Jewish people.

Much of the world nevertheless seems eager to believe lies about Israelis being colonialists - despite the inconvenient fact that the Jews fought colonialism, administered by the British.

Jews have been rooted to Israel (Zion) for nearly 4,000 years, backed by a promise in Genesis 15:18 that God made to the ancient father of all Jews: Abraham.

Muslims have been around only since the exploits of Mohammed - who died in 632 CE.

It would be considered laughable for the natives of any other country to be asked to defend their right to exist; why are Jews expected, after almost 4,000 years on the land, to explain their rights to Israel being their homeland?

Does anyone ask if Germany has a right to exist? Or Kazakhstan?

In today's uncomfortable reality, jihadists do not seem even slightly interested in giving up murdering Jews.

A strong and secure Israel will come only through a dynamic policy of self-defense that will be able to meet those striving for the country's elimination with determination.

The world is not just getting less safe for Jews. It is also rapidly becoming less safe for Christians, Hindus and Muslims deemed by other Muslims to be not Muslim enough.

No one seems to mind having eight officially Islamic states (Afghanistan, Brunei, Iran, Mauritania, Oman, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, and Yemen) and 18 states where Islam is the state religion, and one officially Anglican state, England, but they apparently cannot tolerate one small Jewish state.

As the leaders in the West increasingly lose their moral compass and kneel to appease the radical Jew-haters in their midst, the Jews hold the moral high ground; their critics and enemies do not.

Tawfiq Al-Ghussein's avatar

Reading this brought back a piece of history that is rarely acknowledged. My grandfather, Yacoub Al-Ghussein Bey, served on the Arab Higher Committee and was among those exiled to the Seychelles by the British after the 1936–39 revolt. His removal, together with other leaders, was part of a deliberate effort to dismantle Palestinian political agency and to eliminate the national leadership that had emerged from the general strike. What Ahmed Eldin highlights here is precisely what that generation lived through: a systematic attempt not only to suppress an anti-colonial uprising, but also to erase the memory of a political movement that pre-dated 1948 and articulated a coherent national programme. This history still shapes the present and deserves to be remembered with clarity and accuracy.

Gatitabuzz's avatar

I have watched many movies about the Middle East some funny, some not at all. This one here should be an option onNetflix, Hulu or HBO but I’m glad Apple TV & Prime have it. For as many an option we have for the holocaust *** This too can help all have a bit of enlightenment.

Samantha's avatar

I really want to see this film. Love this bit of writing, says everything so accurately.

Alan, aka DudeInMinnetonka's avatar

In 1937, Arab leader Auni Bey Abdul-Hadi told the Peel Commission:

"There is no such country as Palestine. 'Palestine' is a term the Zionists invented!"

In 1946, Arab historian Philip Hitti testified to the Anglo-American Committee:

"There is no such thing as 'Palestine' in history, absolutely not

Alan, aka DudeInMinnetonka's avatar

In 1937, Arab leader Auni Bey Abdul-Hadi told the Peel Commission:

"There is no such country as Palestine. 'Palestine' is a term the Zionists invented!"

In 1946, Arab historian Philip Hitti testified to the Anglo-American Committee:

"There is no such thing as 'Palestine' in history, absolutely not

Phuck phony phallustinians🐖💨💨

Alan, aka DudeInMinnetonka's avatar

It's all lies

The 1939 flag of Palestine had a star of David on it and Jews identified as Palestinians

Palestine was the Roman name for the land where the Jews were indigenous and autonomous before the Roman colonialists attacked and the name was manifested to subjugate the indigenous people of the land who were the Jews and are the Jews and will be the Jews

Phuck phony phallustinians 🐖💨💨

Nils A. Haug (Gatestone Institute)

Israel is the rightful and eternal ancestral homeland of the Jewish people.

Much of the world nevertheless seems eager to believe lies about Israelis being colonialists - despite the inconvenient fact that the Jews fought colonialism, administered by the British.

Jews have been rooted to Israel (Zion) for nearly 4,000 years, backed by a promise in Genesis 15:18 that God made to the ancient father of all Jews: Abraham.

Muslims have been around only since the exploits of Mohammed - who died in 632 CE.

It would be considered laughable for the natives of any other country to be asked to defend their right to exist; why are Jews expected, after almost 4,000 years on the land, to explain their rights to Israel being their homeland?

Does anyone ask if Germany has a right to exist? Or Kazakhstan?

In today's uncomfortable reality, jihadists do not seem even slightly interested in giving up murdering Jews.

A strong and secure Israel will come only through a dynamic policy of self-defense that will be able to meet those striving for the country's elimination with determination.

The world is not just getting less safe for Jews. It is also rapidly becoming less safe for Christians, Hindus and Muslims deemed by other Muslims to be not Muslim enough.

No one seems to mind having eight officially Islamic states (Afghanistan, Brunei, Iran, Mauritania, Oman, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, and Yemen) and 18 states where Islam is the state religion, and one officially Anglican state, England, but they apparently cannot tolerate one small Jewish state.

As the leaders in the West increasingly lose their moral compass and kneel to appease the radical Jew-haters in their midst, the Jews hold the moral high ground; their critics and enemies do not.🕊️🇮🇱🕊️🇮🇱🕊️🇮🇱🕊️🇮🇱

The Quran States clearly 40 times or more that Israel is for the Jews 24 Arabic Nations exist speaking Arabic yet they consistently and constantly proclaim the lie that Jews in Israel don't belong there yet the year is 5786 and 80 generations of Jews have emanated from the eternal homeland of the Jews with their eternal covenant between the one true God of Abraham Isaac and Jacob unbroken between his chosen people watched over in their Homeland.

Nils A. Haug (Gatestone Institute)

Israel is the rightful and eternal ancestral homeland of the Jewish people.

Much of the world nevertheless seems eager to believe lies about Israelis being colonialists - despite the inconvenient fact that the Jews fought colonialism, administered by the British.

Jews have been rooted to Israel (Zion) for nearly 4,000 years, backed by a promise in Genesis 15:18 that God made to the ancient father of all Jews: Abraham.

Muslims have been around only since the exploits of Mohammed - who died in 632 CE.

It would be considered laughable for the natives of any other country to be asked to defend their right to exist; why are Jews expected, after almost 4,000 years on the land, to explain their rights to Israel being their homeland?

Does anyone ask if Germany has a right to exist? Or Kazakhstan?

In today's uncomfortable reality, jihadists do not seem even slightly interested in giving up murdering Jews.

A strong and secure Israel will come only through a dynamic policy of self-defense that will be able to meet those striving for the country's elimination with determination.

The world is not just getting less safe for Jews. It is also rapidly becoming less safe for Christians, Hindus and Muslims deemed by other Muslims to be not Muslim enough.

No one seems to mind having eight officially Islamic states (Afghanistan, Brunei, Iran, Mauritania, Oman, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, and Yemen) and 18 states where Islam is the state religion, and one officially Anglican state, England, but they apparently cannot tolerate one small Jewish state.

As the leaders in the West increasingly lose their moral compass and kneel to appease the radical Jew-haters in their midst, the Jews hold the moral high ground; their critics and enemies do not.

Jeff G.'s avatar

Eloquently written and informative. I can't wait to see the film. Keep up the fight, Ahmed!

Hela Mansour's avatar

Mabrouk Ahmed! I can’t wait to see it!

Ibrahim Marabeh's avatar

Where can this film be found?

Cihan's avatar

DESCENT PEOPLE OF THE WORLD STAND WITH YOU SISTERS& BROTHERS✊🏻 HUMANITY, JUSTICE AND PASSION WILL WIN🙏💙💪

ZIONIST GENOCIDAL TERRORIST ENTITIES @Israel @USArmy @NATO @EU_Commission WILL BE ANNIHILATED BY THE MORAL WORLD @MFA_China @UN @mfa_russia @GovernmentZA @NicolasMaduro